The Americas | Hard rules for rotten wars

When is it OK to shoot a child soldier?

Canada writes rules for troops who face armed nine-year-olds

|OTTAWA|3 min read

ONE of the worst dilemmas soldiers face is what to do when they confront armed children. International law and most military codes treat underage combatants mainly as innocent victims. They offer guidance on their legal rights and on how to interrogate and demobilise them. They have little to say about a soul-destroying question, which must typically be answered in a split second: when a kid points a Kalashnikov at you, do you shoot him? Last month Canada became the first country to incorporate a detailed answer into its military doctrine. If you must, it says, shoot first.

This article appeared in the The Americas section of the print edition under the headline “When to shoot a child soldier”

The Trump presidency so far

From the April 1st 2017 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
Environment Minister Marina Silva leaves the Committee after arguing with Senator Plinio Valerio

Brazil is bashing its patron saint of the environment

Congress is bulldozing environmental laws. Marina Silva wants to stop it

Illustration of a British lion with a face made of the Argentinian sun, facing away from China and towards a F-16 fighter jet

Inside the secret military dialogue between Britain and Argentina

A deal would counter China and please America. It requires deft diplomacy on the Falklands


A caretaker sits outside a shop during a blackout in Havana, Cuba

Cuba’s leaders fiddle the figures

But they can’t avoid the summer heat—and their disgruntled compatriots


Canada makes a first concession to Donald Trump

Mark Carney is hoping it does not lead to more demands

Brazil’s president is losing clout abroad and unpopular at home

Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva put Brazil on the map, but he hasn’t adapted to a changed world

Brazil’s president is losing clout abroad and unpopular at home

Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva put Brazil on the map, but he hasn’t adapted to a changed world